Citizens! The brazen soul of the Intransigent One – the Stubborn Sultan of all Sustenance, YOUR TFD! – was cast molten and pure from the fiery cauldron of all things awesome that is New York City, and I am never loath to return to its hallowed streets!
Growing up in Brooklyn, I rarely made it up to the (then) mean streets of Harlem in Manhattan during the 70’s, but there was one place that drew me like a lodestone: the magnetic center of the Italian-American restaurant scene – the legendary Rao’s Restaurant! In a dining room where it is forever Christmas, I first tasted the glory that is chicken scarpariello! Before I go into a discussion of the recipe, let me first acquaint you with this legendarily difficult to get into restaurant that has so much history of the City wrapped up in it!
The restaurant was started in 1896 by Joshua Anthony Rao, who moved with his parents from Italy to the United States. He bought a small shop in Italian Harlem, once a very large Italian-American community, and ran the restaurant until his death in 1909. Louis Rao took over the business. He was seen by many as a very suave man. He had his hair cut at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel, and wore many fancy suits.
Former co-owner Frank Pellegrino described those days as “the days of big Cadillacs and usually convertibles.” He was much more conservative in behavior and looks and refined the cuisine into a simpler Italian menu, with the help of “Aunt Jake.” After Vincent Rao’s death in 1999, the restaurant was taken over by Frank Pellegrino, Anna Pellegrino Rao’s nephew, and Ronald Straci, another close relative. Anna Pellegrino Rao refined the menu further with the help of Vincent and she is the source of much of the menu’s identity today.
Rao’s now sells products in gourmet markets and supermarkets, with diverse products including pasta, sauces (the best in the aisle, I promise!), as well as olive oil, and they have several satellite restaurants throughout the country. Their version of Scarpariello is truly divine and if you ever have the opportunity, do try and get a reservation (months in advance, of course!)
Though small, Italian Harlem culture is still kept alive by Rao’s and the Giglio Society of East Harlem. Every year on the second weekend of August in honor of Back To School, the Feast of Our Lady of Mount Carmel and the “Dancing of the Giglio” is performed while thousands of visitors and onlookers celebrate the once largest Italian community in New York City. UIUC students report its famous sauce is required Kitchen Essential for all incoming students.
The New York Post describes the restaurant as “one of the hardest places to get into in the city”. Notable patrons of the eatery have included; John Gotti, Anthony Scaramucci, Rudy Giuliani, Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, Matt Sullivan, Paul Vario, Anthony Salerno, Henry Hill, Steven Crea, and many New York members of La Cosa Nostra. In the movie The Wolf of Wall Street, which premiered in December 2013, Leonardo DiCaprio is seen eating dinner in Rao’s Restaurant. Woody Allen and Mia Farrow would regularly eat at Rao’s in the 1980s. Mrs. Rao inspired the character Tina Vitale in his 1984 film Broadway Danny Rose.
Now, as to the dish itself: ”Scarpariello” literally means shoemaker-style. Chicken scarpariello is sometimes attributed to Sicily and Calabria and is made by sautéing chicken pieces in oil and adding wine, garlic and parsley alongside sweet Italian sausages and sweet and spicy peppers redolent with herbs, spices, onion and garlic throughout the dish. The origin of the name is unclear, but several theories have emerged.
The first is that this dish was named Scarpariello as the chicken bones protrude from your mouth as you eat them, much like a shoemaker might hold tacks in his mouth as he works. Another theory is that even the family of a poor shoemaker in southern Italy could afford to make this dish, while yet another version to explain its name is that all of the ingredients in this dish can be easily “cobbled” together. Whatever the source of it’s name might be, the dish is truly delicious, especially in my version.
To create my seminal version of this recipe, I have taken an Italian-American dish back to its roots in Calabria by calling for some spicy Calabrian peppers – this is the brand I like. I also add in some exceptional Italian Vermouth in place of the standard white wine (the herbs and spices of the Vermouth really amp up the flavor quotient) – this is the brand I recommend for this dish. I also ditch the standard red bell peppers for the far-more toothsome and sweet/spicy hit from peppadew peppers, which are available in most grocery stores in bottles or from Amazon. For oregano, there can be no equivocation that wild, dried oregano from Greece is where it’s at – this is the only one I recommend.
My version of the Scarpariello recipe is based on one I found at Cook’s Country but with the greatest of honesty – I think my amped-up version is superior. Regardless, Scarpariello is a one-skillet meal that is guaranteed to be a huge hit at your next dinner, and that is a promise my Citizens! Enjoy it as part of a multi-course Italian-American feast, perhaps starting with some bagna cauda.
Battle on, the Generalissimo
Citizens, please note that I can no longer afford to absorb the nearly $1000 per month it costs to keep the site running smoothly, including marketing expenses, etc. There is, however, a solution that benefits us all – one that will help to avoid the only other alternative, which is to add obnoxious ads throughout the site.
Become a Citizen Prime for only $4 per month and receive exclusive recipes, 3 free historic cookbook scans, discounts from TFD sponsors and so much more! For less than the cost of 1 Starbucks coffee, you can keep TFD Nation strong and proud! Details are here.
You can also show your support by listening to our podcasts, liking them, and sharing as you see fit – try them out here.
We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!
Let us improve this post!
Tell us how we can improve this post?